Robert Allen’s spinning jenny is broken

The late Eric Hobsbawm famously remarked ‘whoever says Industrial Revolution says cotton’. Traditional accounts of the British Industrial Revolution tell the story of an Asian textile – cotton – transformed into a cheap, mass-produced British staple by means of cost-cutting mechanical inventions. Indeed, technology was centre stage in Adolphe Blanqui’s 1837 Histoire de l’Économie Politique en Europe, the book which offered probably the first systematic application of the concept of industrial revolution. Blanqui insisted that Britain had recently undergone an economic revolution comparable to the social and political revolution experienced in France. In a chapter entitled ‘On the economic revolution in England caused by the discoveries of Watt and Arkwright’, he defined that economic revolution in terms of technology, or, to be more precise, in terms of just two machines:

‘Two machines, henceforth immortal, the steam engine and the spinning machine, overturned the old commercial system and, almost at the same moment, gave birth to material products and social questions unknown to our fathers … Hatched in the brains of Watt and Arkwright, two men of genius, the industrial revolution took possession of England.’

Recent quantitative studies of the classic period of the British Industrial Revolution, from 1760 to 1830, have suggested that overall rates of economic growth were significantly lower than had previously been assumed. Yet despite the tendency to downplay the significance of Industrial Revolution for the economy as a whole, economic historians continue to foreground those technological innovations on which the very notion of Industrial Revolution was originally founded. The question of why the crucial technological innovations were British is central to the two most recent (and influential) general treatments of the Industrial Revolution – Robert Allen’s The British Industrial Revolution in Global Perspective and Joel Mokyr’s The Enlightened Economy: An Economic History of Britain, 1700-1850. Both books employ a distinction between micro- and macro-inventions, identifying James Hargreaves’ spinning jenny and Richard Arkwright’s water frame as key macro-inventions in cotton spinning, along with Samuel Crompton’s later spinning mule, which integrated the principles of the first two machines.

Robert Allen, constructs his argument about technical innovation around Hargreaves’ spinning jenny, famously invented in Oswaldtwistle, Lancashire in the mid-1760s. He offers an explanation for this key macro-invention rooted in economic incentives, in particular in an economy with high wages, but cheap capital and very cheap energy, which rendered worthwhile the high costs of developing macro-inventions and converting them into commercially useful technologies. In his book and an associated article, Allen offers an elaborate cliometric comparison of the jenny’s potential to reduce spinning costs in Britain, France and India. He concludes jennies more than paid for themselves at high British wages for hand spinning, but were not economically advantageous at lower French wage rates, and certainly not at even lower Indian wages. His analysis has been subjected to considerable technical criticism by his fellow cliometricians. However, there is a more profound problem with Allen’s argument. The evidence on which his calculations are based is flawed.

16 spindle version of James Hargreave's spinning jenny, as patented in 1770. Helmshore Mills Textile Museum.

16 spindle version of James Hargreave’s spinning jenny, as patented in 1770. Helmshore Mills Textile Museum.

Allen’s contrast between England and France depends on evidence for low French wages in hand spinning and a correspondingly slow take-up of the spinning jenny in France. He insists that French cotton producers declined to adopt the jenny in any numbers. His evidence is a 1790 French government estimate, which put the number of jennies in the whole of France at only 900, which he contrasts with an estimate of 20,070 jennies for Britain in 1788, almost certainly a considerable exaggeration. He fails, however, to point out that the French estimate was made immediately after the mass machine-breaking riots that accompanied the early months of the French Revolution in the preceding year, 1789. The number of jennies in use in France in the later 1780s was probably much higher, as Jeff Horn has pointed out. Using the small numbers of jennies reported in 1790 cannot demonstrate that the machine was uneconomic in France.

It was certainly not the view of the French government inspectors of manufactures that the jenny was uneconomic. Louis-Casimir Brown, inspector of manufactures for Picardy, reported in 1779 that the jenny ‘combines the advantages 1st of having a yarn of the same degree of twist, 2nd and of a constant fineness, as long as the spinner of the slivers has drawn them out smoothly, 3rd finally it is possible to spin much more’. He provided a detailed breakdown of costs, which indicates a saving over equivalent hand-spun yarn of more than 20%. Eight years later, an evaluation of jennies with 40 spindles spinning cotton at Oissel in Normandy by Jean-Baptiste Goy, the French inspector of manufactures for the Généralité de Rouen, agreed: ‘these machines combine the advantages of reducing labour costs a little, with the production of a yarn that is more uniform’.

Allen is lead further astray by his reliance on French spinning wage data derived from Arthur Young, the English agricultural writer who toured France in 1787-9. Oddly, Allen’s references are not to Young’s own book, Travels during the Years 1787, 1788, and 1789, published shortly after his return to England, but to Constantia Maxwell’s collection of extracts from it, first published in 1929. Nor does Allen reference the wages Young reported for cotton spinning, but rather Young’s averaging of all his observations of spinning earnings across France, including the spinning of flax, hemp, coarse wool, and fine wool, which often paid far less than spinning cotton. Young recorded relatively few observations for cotton spinning wages in France. Those he did report were mainly for Normandy, in the eighteenth century France’s counterpart to Lancashire for cotton manufacturing. Country spinners near Le Havre earned 16 sous per day, at Yvetot in the Caux 12 sous per day, at Rouen, described by Young as ‘the Manchester of France’, 12 sous per day, while good cotton spinners at La Roche-Guyon, to the south-east on the edge of the Normandy cotton spinning zone, earned 12 sous to 15 sous per day. Only at Angers, in Anjou nearly 200 miles to the south-west, did he report lower rates for spinning cotton of 5 sous to 10 sous per day. The 12 sous to 16 sous per day he recorded in Normandy represented 6d. to 8d. a day in English money. That is the mid-range of the 4d. to 10d. a day (assuming a six-day week) Young had previously recorded at Manchester in 1771.

So it is not clear from Young’s data that there was any difference in average wages for hand cotton spinning between the key cotton manufacturing districts in England and France during the years jennies were being introduced. The foundations of the cliometric edifice constructed by Allen to explain international differences in the adoption of the first major spinning innovation of the Industrial Revolution are flawed.

[This is an extract from a longer paper, ‘Fashion, Textiles and the Origins of Industrial Revolution’. It explores the markets for 18th century Lancashire ‘cotton’ textiles and the fibres from which they were woven to re-interpret the key textile inventions of the early Industrial Revolution. The full paper is available at John Styles’ pages, at]

This entry was posted in Spinning Project. Bookmark the permalink.

23 Responses to Robert Allen’s spinning jenny is broken

  1. Holly Dumont says:

    In your research on spinning from 1550-1800, have you come across anything on spinning yarn, not for fabric, but for embroidery?

    I’m working on a Jacobean project, and every darn book says the same thing. (The yarn was wool). I’d like to to know microns, breeds, where would someone like Beth of Hardwick would send to for her embroidery yarn. Was it spun in Shrewsbury? The Earl of Shrewsbury’s Papers indicated: Their income from land was derived mainly from three sources – from rents, from the rich sheep lands of Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire which were kept in hand. (the third was minerals, but that was later).
    But I cannot find any wool processing in this area. I’m sure they didn’t run to the local haberdashery…so any ideas where to look? Has the National Trust or the V/A looked at any of this work with microscopes to tell about the wool? Where can I look? I’ve spent weeks on this project. If I could just get one definitive answer, I could start the dyeing process. Thanks, for any and all help. (I can’t believe how many times I’ve seen the words, “poor woman, spinning white wool”.

  2. Carolyn Penny says:

    Would like to be on your email list for updates to the spinning projects. … worthy endeavor!


    Carolyn Penny, Spinner in North Carolina, USA

  3. daftar poker says:

    Another advantage of playing online is that you can play without
    money in the event you choose. By using cash profit zones, you are not playing from the casino, you’re
    playing against yourself, now this is very very important.
    Live casino games, like live roulette, live blackjack, and
    live baccarat, are around to be played through the comfort
    of your house in the present gambling market.

  4. Situs Bola says:

    First of all I want to say wonderful blog! I had a quick question in which
    I’d like to ask if you do not mind. I was curious to find out how you center yourself and clear your thoughts before writing.
    I’ve had a hard time clearing my thoughts in getting my thoughts out.
    I do take pleasure in writing but it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes
    are usually wasted just trying to figure out how to begin. Any ideas or tips?

  5. Sbobet Asia says:

    I used to be suggested this website by means of my cousin.
    I am no longer sure whether this submit is written through him as nobody else know
    such particular approximately my difficulty.
    You are amazing! Thanks!

  6. Your style is very unique in comparison to other people I’ve read stuff from.

    I appreciate you for posting when you’ve got the opportunity, Guess I
    will just bookmark this web site.

  7. Unquestionably consider that which you said. Your favorite justification appeared to be
    on the net the easiest thing to consider of. I say to
    you, I certainly get annoyed at the same time as other people consider concerns that they just do not recognize about.

    You controlled to hit the nail upon the highest and
    outlined out the whole thing with no need side-effects , people could take a
    signal. Will likely be back to get more. Thanks

  8. It’s genuinely very difficult in this busy life to listen news on TV, so I only use internet
    for that purpose, and take the latest information.

  9. I believe that is among the so much vital info for me.
    And i’m glad reading your article. However want to observation on few common issues, The site
    taste is perfect, the articles is in reality excellent :
    D. Excellent process, cheers

  10. Thanks , I have just been looking for info approximately this subject for a while and yours is the
    best I’ve discovered till now. However, what in regards
    to the bottom line? Are you certain about the source?

  11. depoxito says:

    The best in class, Depoxito offer you high-end experience that direct the look and vibes of authentic VIP standarts, we
    have the funds for you the best enthralling to high-level experience of VIPs expect
    in any summit end casino, grand liven up casino royale pay for you
    the other studio design element including the grand blackjack,
    offering our VIP Customer the best experience of a Salon privee table.

    New style table plus feature across the room in the same way as grand roulette upgraded on our provider playtechs mini prestige roulette which delivering more engaging and richer playing experience.
    The other experience contains a sum of seven tables including five blackjack tables, one roulette table and one baccarat table.
    Grand stimulate casino royale has been high hand-engineered to fit the
    needs of our customer to using it, and contains unique elements that
    is specially intended to maximize the impact value
    we got from our customers and diversify it to the existing network.

    Soon, Depoxito will develop an better reality technology on live casino
    for our VIP member, these most innovative
    technology ever seen in living casino including this improved reality.

    Which allow players to experience products upon an entire further
    level which is never seen before literally leaping out of the game and taking the blackjack,
    baccarat, roulette and further game into the combined entire
    Depoxito VIP Baccarat, we find the money for you the categorically exclusive flesh and blood
    VIP Baccarat that is played later than going on to 7 players at the same table and our highly trained lovely living baccarat dealer.
    And of course our VIP member will feel as if they were in reality sitting at one of
    the summit casino baccarat table. This immersive
    gaming experience creates a hugely carefree song that our VIP
    players will locate hard to surpass.
    Here is the list of liven up casino game that
    depoxito provide, we come up with the money for the widest range of live
    casino games on the shout from the rooftops including : blackjack
    unlimited, blackjack prestige, roulette, baccarat, poker, hi-lo, sic bo, and grand bring to life casino royale such
    as Grand Baccarat, Grand Blackjack and Grand Roulette for our VIP member.
    And of course as a aficionado of Depoxito you can enjoy every the
    games that we present to you, every you habit to attain is just visit our site depoxito
    and register it forlorn takes in the works to 3 minutes and then youre normal to enactment any
    game that you want.
    Be our VIP, physical our VIP enthusiast of course
    contracted you the best encouragement you can acquire from us all you craving to be a VIP member is completely easy.
    every you dependence is just save playing upon our site,
    enlargement and act out as soon as a VIP as soon as the amount that our company had written, keep playing and our customer benefits will gain access to you that you are promoted
    to become a VIP enthusiast upon our site.

  12. I am genuinely happy to read this blog posts which includes lots of helpful data, thanks for providing
    these information.

  13. Option Links to Official Online Gambling Sites

    Now in a good all-sophisticated era, everyone may access the web very very easily.
    Until now many free games that can be played by everyone,
    one example is online gambling games. With the appointment regarding gambling that used to be only on terrain, now an online program has made it very easy for
    many gambling gamers to channel their interests in the world
    regarding online gambling.

    But before an individual want to play gambling
    which can be now online program. You’ve still got to learn typically the characteristics of trusted online gambling sites.

    Why will be that? Because in the particular online world there are still online gambling sites that cheat.

    Definition of Alternative Links
    An alternative link is usually a link provided simply by a reliable online
    gambling agent to prevent blocking when you want to
    enter in or access their web site.

    How to Get Alternate Backlinks
    When you previously know the meaning of alternative links, we will offer some
    steps to get alternative links:
    1. An individual can look at the main internet gambling sites.
    Usually these people will provide alternative link information with their site.

    2. The second step is to be able to directly contact Livechat,
    a person can directly ask the customer service on obligation
    3. You can notice an alternative link in order to your
    trusted online gambling site through the set of online gambling
    sites below.

  14. l69 says:

    Option Link l69
    L69 is one of the official sites that offer the
    most recent alternative link trusted online betting sites.
    L69 provides more than one alternative link from every betting site,
    and all of us here have become probably the most comprehensive alternative link
    companies and the L69 internet site includes a responsive display that
    will makes it easy for you to access our site from the display of your own gizmo or
    laptop. Plus what you have to know is of which we here only
    have 1 official link, l69. myself and if there usually are
    other websites that offer information or call the website is not our own official site.

    Ball wagering and casino gambling are usually types of
    games that are very popular with the folks of Indonesia. Why l69?

    Since we’ve been here for more than five a number of possess become the trust
    associated with the folks of Indonesia as a place to perform soccer gambling and in addition on-line casino gambling.
    Itself in addition has obtained a license through the Asian and Western european governments last
    year to turn out to be an online gambling gambling provider site in Asian countries and Europe.

    By offering many different types of betting bets which can be played upon one ID, it makes the particular members feel happy enjoying in your
    Benefits of Alternative Links l69
    But regrettably lately there are usually many members who knowledge problems and problems any time entering into their Bola tangkas
    game for the reason that Sbobet site is often blocked and several older sites have been obstructed by the Indonesian federal government
    rather than a few are also influenced by what is called the Newsletter Task.

    The Indonesian government these days is struggling to eradicate
    links or paths to get into sites that smell of pornography, gambling
    and there are many other content of which is deemed inappropriate.

  15. Sbobetberry says:

    Agen Slot Joker123 Terpercaya in Indonesia

    Speaking of existing trends, internet technology is becoming more
    advanced that has made typically the online gambling industry grow.
    In case you are enthusiastic about trying slot online games, we would recommend a
    best in addition to trusted online betting site
    in Philippines known as Joker123. This provider provides various types associated
    with games which are regarding international standard, all available games are
    guaranteed to end up being official as nicely as quality.

  16. Established Sbobet Indonesia Agent

    Sbobet is a gambling company which was much in need by the
    men and women associated with Indonesia. Unfortunately,
    choosing football gambling games on the net these days
    cannot be done haphazardly because not all Bola tangkas Indonesia agents provide the particular same service even among those who make use of the name of the Agent being a cover for committing crimes for example fraud,
    theft and embezzlement.

    Of course as a fan of online gambling games you
    must remain cautious and try out hard to avoid these unwanted losses.

    That is why, in this particular article, we want to be able to give
    you a few tips and tricks that you can do so that you are
    able to continue to revenue while playing online betting
    on the internet.

    Features of Trusted Football Gambling Brokers
    The most crucial thing that you can know, particularly for those
    of you who are just beginning to sign up for are some criteria that a Sbobet Indonesia agent must have so that it will end up being easier for you to choose as a playing
    Listed here are some of the criteria that must be owned by Sbobet Official gambling agents:
    – Customer support or customer support that is always active
    twenty-four hours a day.
    – Game variants complete along with international standard products.

    – Serve various techniques of financial transactions and can become done through leading regional banks.

    – Provides games from various well-known firms such as Sbobet,
    Nova88, Maha168 and others.
    – Do not have a minimum or even maximum limit to pay the winnings.

    The five criteria above are typically the minimum
    conditions that should be owned by a new trusted online betting web site.
    So make sure the particular site you choose fulfills the five conditions previously

    Reasons for Choosing a Depobola Sbobet Agent Partner
    Choosing a site amongst millions of agents which
    are spread on the web is not a fairly easy issue.
    It may take days and even months if an individual have to search with regard to yourself, you will really feel tired before
    you can even begin the game.
    Therefore we all want to simplify your work here so
    you can immediately play and get more benefits from sportsbook games.

    Depobola is a new site that connects on the internet gambling fans with a selection of international quality gambling games provided by trustworthy gambling companies such because
    Official Sbobet Broker Depobola has obtained a good official license directly from the Sbobet provider to spread out
    access for potential customers to all variants
    of typically the game which have been offered.
    By choosing Depobola as a new playing partner, players automatically get an abundant revenue that players is not
    going to obtain from other Sbobet Philippines agent sites in Indonesia.

    Here are some of the strengths of Depobola:
    – Easy and Hassle-free Deposit Method
    We possess collaborated with several well-known local banks in Indonesia so that the
    deposit can be done comfortably and safely. Players also do not
    need to make a deposit in overseas currency because we furthermore accommodate customers who create deposits in rupiah.

    If the player is not cozy setting up a deposit through
    a bank account which you have, the particular Player
    does not need to worry since there are some other deposit options that gamers can do,
    namely via OVO payment services. Typically the minimum deposit
    is likewise low so the participant doesn’t have to hesitate in order to try first having fun with Depobola.

    – Seductive Bonuses and Promos
    The advantage that will players can get together with Depobola is not just from winning hanging around nevertheless also bonuses
    and promos provided solely for the particular good thing about loyal members that have chosen us because playing partners.

    – Simple and Fast Enrollment
    Getting an official member through Depobola is very easy, it only takes a few mins, you can immediately join the game.
    All you need to do is click the “REGISTER” button from the top of this page.

  17. agenmaxbet says:

    Userbola is a trustworthy maxbet agent that has collaborated with official maxbet providers since 2014.

    We are tasked with serving betting players who wish to sign up for an recognized maxbet
    account in Indonesia. We here as a maxbet list site also have an recognized PAGCOR license to market internet gambling online games.

    In addition, Userbola as a maxbet agent always gets positive input from betting members such as fast
    deal services, safe payments and complete betting games.
    The data of members who have registered at a trusted maxbet
    agent userbola are also protected properly. The userbola team also
    always provides benefits to all betting members every week
    such as a rebate reward or cashback that you will not get on the official maxbet
    site. From the assessment of our own betting members and official providers who have made userbola the number 1 trustworthy maxbet agent in Indonesia.

    How to Register a Maxbet Account
    Online gambling players who want to sign up for a maxbet account through the trusted maxbet listing site userbola only need some important data like
    the full name based on the banking account, account number, contact number that can be contacted, and
    email address. These data can be filled in via the registration form on our website.

  18. says:

    Ubobet is an internationally trusted gambling dealer
    back 2001 until now. By holding qualified permission for online gambling sites
    that present various types of betting games. Games easily reached tally up Sportsbook,
    enliven Casino and Cockfight. Ubobet has reached
    the entire world gambling spread around including the Indonesian market.
    At present, every morning there are more than 100 thousand players
    who entrust their bets in the city of Ubobet.

    Ubobet List Site

    To register an account, players cannot realize it
    directly upon the Ubobet site. In other words, prospective players must register
    through the approved agent site for Ubobet listings such as Pandora188.
    By using Pandora188 ID the artiste can bet upon this city.
    How to register is quite easy, just by filling out the registration form correctly.
    After that make a deposit of at least 25 thousand, after that the artist
    can bet on Ubobet. all player who joins as a advocate
    at Pandora188 is entitled to a freebet extra and along with a
    daily addition bonus without exception.

    Ubobet Login

    After registering, players can log in on Ubobet in two ways.
    The first is through attributed partners who have collaborations such as Pandora188.

    Because the two sites have already formed a partnership, which means that betting on the Pandora188
    site is the thesame as betting on Ubobet directly. Or by the second
    pretentiousness you can directly log in to
    the Ubobet site if you already have an account.
    How to log in Ubobet is quite easy, just enter
    your ID & password correctly.

  19. Mahaslot says:

    There are fittingly many popular online slot games that you
    can locate on the internet. every of them allow all but
    the similar activity and of course the abundant abet that you can unexpectedly get overnight.
    Getting rich in a hasty epoch is now no longer just a determination because it
    is possible to do.

    One of the online gambling that you should attempt to enjoy is
    called online slots. This game has been regarding for hundreds of years and is nevertheless well-liked today.
    You could say slot gambling games are a type of gambling that has evolved hence rapidly, starting from the shape, appearance, to the game format.
    No gambling game can be as innovative as the newest online slots.

    For those of you who are just starting to explore the online gambling business, here we will part basic tips and
    tricks for achievement in online slot gambling games. These tips will not put up to you save winning in every game but will make your chances of
    winning bigger and cut the number of losses you will encounter.

  20. Ioncasino says:

    Ion Casino

    Ion casino is a trusted and best on-line casino site coming from 2010 which includes offered millions of gamers in Asia.
    Ion casino or also known as Ionclub is the top ranking option site because it provides the greatest experience for online gambling
    players in Dalam negri. With an official license to function, this provider ensures that players make bets without
    chance, credibility and could be trusted.

  21. Florine says:

    For newest information you have to visit world wide web and on the
    web I found this web site as a finest web site for most up-to-date updates.

  22. Veronique says:

    Panduanjudi Login

    Panduanjudi is a trusted and approved poker site from PKV games server.
    We pay for 9 types of vanguard games that can be played using just one ID.
    The games we come up with the money for total poker, domino99, bandarq, aduq,
    sakong, bandar66 and afterward capsa susun. In adjunct to having a large variety of games, furthermore has several handsome promos that can be
    enjoyed directly after inborn registered as a member.
    later truth weekly cashback promos that are calculated
    from the sum turnover, both winning and losing.
    besides Panduanjudi in reality appreciate if there are members who
    invite contacts or relatives to deed on our site by giving a referral further of 10%
    to 20% of the number of turnover downline invited to play.

    To be the best poker site, Panduanjudi is always exasperating to total our facilities to be clever
    to have the funds for the best experience in playing poker at our place.
    One of the ways is the Gambling guide provides a means of payment that reaches every elements
    of Indonesian society. By functioning similar
    to leading banks and compliant Simpati and XL savings account deposits.
    As well as which players can make deposits using E-wallets
    such as GoPay, OVO and Funds. other than those mentioned above, of course there are yet advantages in Panduanjudi to vacillate to become the best poker
    sites such as:

  23. Indonesia’s Best and Many Complete Online Slot Gambling

    The Userbolavip site provides also been pre-loaded with various features which are intended for the safety and comfort and ease of loyal customers throughout Indonesia.
    By simply registering as a member an individual can immediately enjoy a variety of
    sophisticated and attractive features that this best
    in addition to most trusted on the internet slot
    gambling internet site Userbolavip has.

    Total type of online game
    By becoming the member of the Userbolavip online gambling site, you can find various sorts of online gambling games.

    Not only slot machines, here you may also find some other popular types of games such as soccer gambling or even sports betting, on line casino gambling, poker, and so on. All games are also guaranteed quality since they are provided by
    the particular best gambling online sites in the

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.